What Type Of Investor Are You?

“To achieve satisfactory investment results is easier than most people realize; to achieve superior results is harder than it looks.”
— Benjamin Graham, ‘The Intelligent Investor’

Or better yet, what type of investor do you want to become? For all intents and purposes we are going to limit your selection to 3 choices:

  1. Passive Investor
  2. Enterprising Investor
  3. Hybrid Investor

It is important you make this decision early, for it will decide what types of investments you pursue, the amount of time you allocate towards your investments and the potential gains and losses you could experience.

The Hybrid Investor

“We must learn our limits. We are all something, but none of us are everything.” — Blaise Pascal

From the outset the Hybrid Investor is very similar to the Passive Investor. You leverage the power of Index Funds. Where the two differ is that you are actively pursuing an investment education with the Hybrid approach: teaching yourself finance and business basics, developing a multitude of mental models, devouring countless books and business news. The purpose being to eventually practice a combination of Passive and Enterprising investment; hence the Hybrid Investor.

However, it is of extreme importance you are true to yourself while pursuing the Hybrid approach, due to the Lake Wobegon effect. You will hit a point, during your investment studies, where you will get it, or not get it, just like in Calculus class; but without ∂’s. It is important you catch this, because profiting from individual stock investments over long periods of time is not easily achieved, and a poor understanding of the fundamentals that go into successful enterprising investing, will prove detrimental to your wealth. So when you find yourself not grasping the gist of what you’ve been studying either: 1. Give it more time and more effort or 2. Stick with Passive investing.

So the formula works out like this: as you become more adept at business analysis you slow your investment in Index funds and start placing big dollars in the stock of companies you find to be intelligent investments; that is, those which provide an adequate margin of safety and possess favorable business prospects (all of this is to be covered in immense detail in upcoming blog posts).

Advantages:

  • Have the option to spend minimal time managing your investments
  • The option to guarantee yourself average market returns
  • Has the potential to outperform the market
  • Potential for large gains

Disadvantages:

  • Requires time to hone a strong investment aptitude
  • Has the potential to never outperform the market
  • Has the potential to underperform the market
  • Potential for large losses
The Enterprising Investor

“The enterprising investor, by definition will devote a fair amount of his attention and efforts toward obtaining a better than run-of-the-mill investment result.” — Benjamin Graham, ‘The Intelligent Investor’

The Enterprising Investor is who many retail investors strive to become and in pursuit deal blow after blow to their financial well being. It is important we draw a bold line between our definition of an Enterprising Investor and what you might deem an Enterprising Investor; as you may be talking about a Speculator.

Benjamin Graham has done such a fine job of explaining what it means to be an investor and what it means to be a speculator, that I am forced to quote him at length.

“An investment operation is one which, upon thorough analysis promises safety of principal and an adequate return. Operations not meeting these requirements are speculative.”
– Benjamin Graham, ‘The Intelligent Investor’

Compare that with the purchase of a few shares of stock by an inexperienced member of the public who has some largely emotional conviction that they will be able to profit from their “investment”.

“…in the easy language of Wall Street, everyone who buys or sells a security has become an investor, regardless of what he buys, or for what purpose or at what price, or whether for cash or on margin.”

Even if you understand the difference between Investing and Speculating, but still want to speculate, heed to this advice:

“Speculation is always fascinating, and it can be a lot of fun while you are ahead of the game. If you want to try your luck at it, put aside a portion- the smaller the better- of your capital in a separate fund for this purpose. Never add more money to this account just because the market has gone up and profits are rolling in. Never mingle your speculative and investment operations in the same account nor in any part of your thinking.” — Benjamin Graham, ‘The Intelligent Investor’

Now that speculation’s been taken care of, lets talk about becoming a real Enterprising Investor.

In order to become a profitable Enterprising Investor one must first obtain a strong investment education. It is because of this, I believe most people reading right now are ill-prepared to become Enterprising Investors; and is why I created the Hybrid Investor, details to follow in my next post.

Advantages:

  • Has the potential to outperform the market

Disadvantages:

  • Most people reading this are not ready to become Enterprising Investors
  • Has the potential to underperform the market
  • Requires significant amounts time
  • Large potential losses

The Passive Investor

“Most of us have no chance of being as good as the average in any pursuit that others practice for hours to hone their skills. Anyone, however can be as good as the average in the stock market with no practice at all.” — JeremySiegel, ‘Stocks for the Long Run’

The passive investor is the ideal investment approach for most of the people reading this. The passive investor will guarantee themselves average returns by investing in Index Funds and therefore will never do worse then the market; but also never do better.

Considering many retail investors do worse then the market average, this is a highly attractive approach. However, Index investing lacks the sexiness of buying individual stocks and due to this lack of sexiness many retail investors feel that in order to be considered ‘cool’ they should avoid the un-sexy Index funds and buy the sexy individual stocks; pure folly.

Sadly we’ve all had at least one friend, cousin, brother or sister brag about how they “day trade“, projecting a huge smile while saying this proudly; or a huge frown, if they’ve already experienced its pitfalls. That being said, when it comes to investing leave your high school mentality at the door and just worry about building wealth.

Advantages:

  • Spend minimal time managing your investments
  • Guarantee yourself average market returns
  • Never do worse then the market

Disadvantages:

  • Almost impossible to outperform the market